| 2021 D Cox |
| 2020 R Graham |
| 2019 R Graham |
| 2018 D.P. Courtnadge |
| 2017 R Graham |
| 2016 S R Gregory |
| 2015 S R Gregory |
| 2014 D P Courtnadge |
| 2013 R Graham |
| * 2012 R Amos |
| 2011 R J Connell R |
| 2010 D P Courtnadge |
| 2009 D P Courtnadge |
| 2008 K Laidlow R |
| 2007 K Laidlow R |
| 2006 Howard Forster |
| 2005 G Young |
| 2004 R Graham |
| 2003 R Graham |
| 2002 A Adams R |
| * 2001 K Rutherford |
| * 2000 K Rutherford |
| 1999 A W Pearson R |
| 1998 D P Courtnadge |
| * 1997 J Cunningham |
| 1996 A G Veitch R |
| * 1995 P W Courtnadge |
| 1994 G Young |
| * 1993 P W Courtnadge |
| * 1992 E Edwards |
| * 1991 Ah Soo Chen |
| * 1990 J W Clarkson |
| 1989 J Cunningham |
| 1988 Harold Forster R |
| 1987 Howard Forster |
| 1986 I S Dinnis |
| 1985 J Brewis R |
| 1984 A E Patrick |
| * 1983 GDJ Spence |
| 1982 T A Little |
| 1981 G Hepplewhite R |
| 1980 T A Little |
| * 1979 A I Bainbridge |
| * 1978 T A Henderson |
| 1977 R M Holland R |
| * 1976 Ah Soo Chen |
| * 1975 L O’Neil |
| * 1974 H Reed |
| 1973 E Edwards |
| * 1972 W A Armstrong |
| 1971 J Spearman R |
| * 1970 WM Alder |
| 1969 J W Cresswell R |
| * 1968 H M Harrison |
| * 1967 J W Clarkson |
| * 1966 D A Philipson |
| * 1965 T E Oliver |
| * 1964 C S Spearman |
| * 1963 J H Ogram |
| * 1962 J H Barrable |
| * 1961 R A Symm |
| * 1960 D Peggs |
| * 1959 S F Dickinson |
| * 1958 J Symm |
| * 1957 J Holland |
| * 1956 O R Poteous |
| * 1955 W M Walker |
| * 1954 J Spearman |
| * 1953 G S Clarkson |
| * 1952 W Hogarth |
| * 1951 T R Moffett |
| * 1950 J J Cresswell |
| * 1949 T G Huddlestone |
| * 1948 E C Haggis |
| * 1947 J R Tait |
| * 1946 B Hanson |
| * 1945 G W Umpleby |
| * 1944 J S Telford |
| * 1943 J W Bright |
| * 1942 J E Moffitt |
| * 1941 T Slater |
| * 1940 J P Thompson |
| * 1939 I Barry |
| * 1938 J M Heslop |
| * 1937 J B Spearman |
| * 1936 W Stevenson |
| * 1935 J E Marshall |
R = Resigned, * = Deceased
Hextoldesham Lodge No. 5577 